Billy Joel has deeply resonated with audiences through his poignant, Americana-inspired lyrics. Whether it’s in “Scenes from an Italian Restaurant,” which tells the tale of high school sweethearts Brenda and Eddie up until their divorce, or the iconic “Piano Man,” which paints vivid portraits of strangers passing time in a lounge, Joel captures the essence of everyday life.
From the outset, Joel has had a unique ability to express the American experience and reveal the complexities behind the ‘American Dream.’ One of the standout examples is “Allentown,” a single from his 1982 album The Nylon Curtain.
“Allentown” delves into the struggles of young blue-collar Americans in towns within the declining Rust Belt. While centered around a specific location, the song serves as a metaphor for disillusionment, highlighting how many were sold an idealized version of the American Dream but faced a starkly different reality. Joel reflects this sentiment in the lyrics: “Every child had a pretty good shot / to get at least as far as their old man got / But something happened on the way to that place / They threw an American flag in our face.”
Though some of his lyrics lean toward a political message, Joel sees himself primarily as a storyteller. He once remarked, “How can you not write about it? This is what I see. This is what’s happening in this country. I’m not trying to be Bob Dylan, but as a songwriter, you write about what you observe.”
The song received mixed reactions, with some critics arguing that Joel played into negative stereotypes of working-class life, particularly because he had achieved significant success as an artist. In The Complete Albums Collection, he addressed these sentiments, stating, “There was this attitude of ‘Who is he to talk about being unemployed? He’s a rich rock star.’ I found it ironic. You think I don’t know about unemployment? I’ve experienced it more than most.”
Despite the controversy, “Allentown” resonated with many in the town, leading to a campaign that gathered 10,000 signatures for Joel to perform there. True to his roots, he did perform on December 27, 1982, at Stabler Arena in nearby Bethlehem, Pennsylvania—a town also referenced in the song and once home to the Bethlehem Steel Company.
Joel opened and closed the concert with “Allentown,” receiving an extended standing ovation. He was later presented with a key to the city by Mayor Joseph Daddona, who described the song as “a gritty anthem for a gritty city.”
What do you think?
Show comments / Leave a comment