Ranking Every Album by Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds from Least to Most Acclaimed

1. The First Born is Dead (1985)

Nick Cave and The Bad Seeds’ second album made a bold statement, cementing their dark reputation within post-punk. This record showcases Cave’s fixation on the American South, intertwined with the gritty energy of Berlin, where it was recorded. He recalled in Rolling Stone Australia, “Berlin gave us the freedom to explore without judgment… Unlike in London, where we often felt dismissed.”

2. No More Shall We Part (2001)

Emerging four years after their previous album, this early 2000s effort struggled under the shadow of The Boatman’s Call, especially amid Cave’s personal battles with addiction. His recovery not only improved his artistry but also showcased the band’s musical prowess. Yet, when compared to their classic works, it feels a bit incomplete.

3. Kicking Against The Pricks (1986)

Cave’s approach to this 1986 covers album was unorthodox, discarding reverence for the originals. He expressed disdain for some of the reimagined tracks, asserting they weren’t well executed to begin with. While it boasts an enjoyable charm, it reflects Cave’s preference for originality.

4. Your Funeral My Trial (1986)

Ranking Nick Cave’s albums is subjective, and this one is notably special to him. He once shared, “It’s my favorite… with perfect songs like ‘The Carny’ and ‘Stranger Than Kindness.’” Cave’s affection for the record is evident, making it a beloved addition to their discography.

5. Wild God (2024)

A shift in status for Cave, this 2024 release opens with dramatic spoken word, setting an extravagant tone. The album is ambitious and powerful, but fans might still reach for older favorites like Push the Sky Away or Ghosteen when in need of nostalgia.

6. The Good Son (1990)

After the heavier tones of Your Funeral… My Trial, this album provides a lighter contrast, born from Cave’s experience of finding happiness in Brazil. He described it as a reflection of his good early days there, although he later noted the cultural adjustments required for survival.

7. Dig Lazarus Dig! (2008)

After a hiatus to focus on Grinderman, Cave returned with Dig, Lazarus, Dig!, tackling the Lazarus story through a modern lens in a bustling New York City. The album’s adventurous spirit is infused with angst and creativity.

8. Nocturama (2003)

This record blends various musical styles, propelled by the band’s chaotic energy. Producer Nick Launay remembered the intensity of their sessions, capturing an essence that sets the album apart in their catalog.

9. Henry’s Dream (1992)

The introduction of new band members shaped this album, despite Cave’s self-criticism about its production. He insisted on giving the songs justice, which resonates in its predatory energy and compelling narratives.

10. Ghosteen (2019)

This deeply personal album, written in the shadow of his son’s death, combines vulnerability and beauty. Cave emphasized the album’s aim to uplift the listener, celebrating life’s splendor amid sorrow.

11. Tender Prey (1988)

This darker offering features the iconic ‘The Mercy Seat’ and allows listeners a glimpse into Cave’s troubled psyche. Despite being a product of chaos, its haunting melodies elevate it above others in their repertoire.

12. Push The Sky Away (2013)

Their first release on their own label, this introspective album focuses on the beauty of the surreal and strange, marking a thoughtful progression in Cave’s songwriting and musical exploration.

13. Abattoir Blues/Lyre of Orpheus (2004)

Typically seen as a standout, this album boasted a mix of chaos and precision. Cave’s dark storytelling remained potent, and its division into two parts allowed for distinct self-expression.

14. From Her to Eternity (1984)

Their debut album introduces Cave’s wry humor and lyrical prowess, filled with vivid imagery and a fresh take on the punk scene. It has since become a vital part of their identity.

15. Let Love In (1994)

In this album, love emerges prominently amid Cave’s signature themes of violence. It reflects a more refined version of his earlier works, signaling a turning point in his musical career.

16. Murder Ballads (1996)

Best known for its gruesome storytelling, Murder Ballads features collaborations with other artists, propelling its notoriety. The haunting ‘O’Malley’s Bar’ serves as a chilling cornerstone for this iconic record.

17. The Skeleton Tree (2016)

This album stands as Cave’s most poignant, crafted during a tumultuous time of personal loss. Its raw introspection and bold departure from earlier styles solidified it as a masterpiece born from grief.

18. The Boatman’s Call (1997)

Widely considered Cave’s magnum opus, this atmospheric album strips away pretension to reveal profound vulnerability. With haunting melodies and lyrics, it epitomizes the band’s artistry and emotional depth.